by Thomas M. Pender
Fans of the performers mentioned herein will no doubt cry “Foul!” and state films in which their idols were astounding. I hereby disclaim that yes, just as all good actors may have a bad performance here and there, bad actors may trip and actually perform well on rare occasions. I’m talking about career-length patterns of badness here.
Acting is the art of being able to convince an audience that you are going through a fictional experience via the power of your actions and reactions. The better you are at emoting, the more the audience will believe that you are the character you portray.
Understanding this, there are some “actors” who have made much more money than you or I for no reason at all! While listed as actors, they make no attempt whatsoever to emote . . . or pretend to emote . . . or raise an eyebrow . . . or fluctuate a monotone. These automatons truly astound me, as people keep paying to see them in films!
I laughed aloud when I learned that Keanu Reeves had been cast as the robot Klaatu in the remake of the classic science fiction film The Day The Earth Stood Still! What type casting! You need someone to act as though they have never once made a facial expression? Call up Mr. Reeves! Although best known for the cartoonily animated character of Ted Logan in the Bill and Ted “dude”fest films, Keanu Reeves has peppered silver screens with emotionless characters such as Matt in River’s Edge (the one film in which his apathetic nature was key to the plot), the plastic-mannered cop Johnny Utah in Point Break, the too-proper Jonathan Harker in Dracula, the expressionless Johnny Mnemonic, Neo in The Matrix franchise . . . this isn’t happenstance, this guy thinks this is a “style”!
Tim Robbins has directed many a fine film, but like Quentin Tarantino, should keep himself behind the camera! Robbins started out quite animated: the freaked-out “Merlin” in Top Gun, the horny Ebby LaLoosh in Bull Durham, and the Pythonian-Viking-y title role of Erik the Viking are all fine examples of facial and vocal expressions of emotions. Ever since he zoned his way through Jacob’s Ladder, however, he seems to have never recovered. He never raised or lowered his verbal dial tone a smidge throughout Mystic River, The Shawshank Redemption, or even his new-ager cameo in High Fidelity. It seems Robbins is more than comfortable in “sleep” mode.
I can think of one film – one! — in which John Malkovich did not play a walking doorstop. His comic turn as the Hannibal Lechter ripoff Cyrus “The Virus” Grissom in Con Air did inspire my laughter, simply because it was delightful to see Malkovich try for once in his illustrious career! He is the king of monotone delivery and unaffected personae, from the dim Lennie Small in 1992’s Gary Sinise version of Of Mice And Men to the cold Gen. Simms in Mulholland Falls to the deflated Herman Mankiewicz in RKO 281 to the calculating Tom Ripley in Ripley’s Game . . . not a smile in the bunch!
Speaking of non-smiling, David Duchovny seems bored with his own performances in just about everything he does, from X Files to Playing God to . . . hell, everything he’s ever done! Let’s just be honest about that. While his eyebrows may occasionally suggest the hint of an emotion, his flat, monotonous, sleepy and sleep-inducing, robotic, automaton, dial tone voice suggests nothing but . . . nothing! He seems unimpressed, disengaged, catatonic, and about a dozen other Roget words for not a good actor.
I do, however, have the next big idea to get all of these guys working in an impressive way. Picture it: Keanu Reeves, Tim Robbins, John Malkovich and David Duchovny starring in Night of the Living Dead!!!!!!!!!!!